Roadmap / 0.1.3.7
What the 400,000 does, and why
v0.1.3.7, commit 3b5a178. File docs/RESULTS_v0.1.3.7_mobilization_permutations.md.
Written at this version and not revised since. Later versions may change these numbers; see the roadmap.
Switch: canada_mobilization.mode (unchanged).
New option value: canada_mobilization.level: share, with share (0 = today's reserves, 1 = the full plan), resolve_saturation (default 0.5) and resolve_growth (saturating or linear).
Runs: 3,000 paired runs per variant, every other module on, v0.1.3.5 defaults. 222,000 new runs; 285,000 with v0.1.3.6. 32 tests pass.
Scope: aggregate strengths only. No units, sites or tactics.
Headline
- All of the plan's value in a full annexation comes from its effect on Canada's will to continue. With that effect switched off, the 400,000 make Canada's odds worse than today (−2.0 points). With only that effect, the gain is +5.5.
- That effect is one hand-set parameter. It cuts the chance Canada capitulates by 10 to 40% and is complete at half fill. If it grows in proportion to the size of the plan instead, the full plan is worth +12.1 points, not +4.3.
- The first half of the plan does the work. Gains are +0.9, +2.2, +5.1, +4.6 and +4.3 points at 10%, 25%, 50%, 75% and 100% of the way from today to the full plan.
- Two findings are model weaknesses, not results: training has no effect after the opening fight, and Canadian deaths push a mobilized Canada toward capitulation exactly as they push an unmobilized one.
- Allies are worth more than the plan: +6.3 points against +4.3.
Results: full annexation
US withdrawal with today's reserves is 66.8%. Changes are against that, with 95% intervals.
How much of the plan
| Share of the gap closed | People added | US withdraws | Change | US deaths | Canadian deaths |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (today) | 4,384 | 66.8% | — | 1,331 | 10,297 |
| 10% | 41,600 | 67.7% | +0.9 (+0.6 to +1.3) | 1,405 | 10,786 |
| 25% | 97,400 | 69.0% | +2.2 (+1.7 to +2.8) | 1,508 | 11,474 |
| 50% | 190,400 | 71.9% | +5.1 (+4.3 to +5.9) | 1,694 | 12,699 |
| 75% | 283,400 | 71.4% | +4.6 (+3.8 to +5.3) | 1,810 | 13,599 |
| 100% (full) | 376,400 | 71.1% | +4.3 (+3.6 to +5.0) | 1,903 | 14,394 |
The three jobs, switched off in turn (full plan)
| Variant | US withdraws | Change | Canada capitulates |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opening fight only (no cadres, no will effect) | 66.4% | −0.4 (−0.6 to −0.2) | 32.5% |
| All the fighting, no will effect | 64.8% | −2.0 (−2.6 to −1.4) | 34.6% |
| Will effect, no cadres | 72.3% | +5.5 (+4.7 to +6.3) | 26.1% |
| The whole plan | 71.1% | +4.3 (+3.6 to +5.0) | 28.0% |
If the will effect keeps growing
| Variant | US withdraws | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 75% of the way, linear | 75.4% | +8.6 (+7.6 to +9.6) |
| Full plan, linear | 78.9% | +12.1 (+11.0 to +13.3) |
| Best case: linear, all armed, trained, cadre cap doubled | 78.4% | +11.6 (+10.5 to +12.7) |
Other permutations of the full plan
| Variant | US withdraws | Change | US deaths | Canadian deaths |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One in five supplementary armed | 71.3% | +4.5 | 1,765 | 13,746 |
| All armed | 70.6% | +3.8 | 2,015 | 14,931 |
| Supplementary effectiveness tripled (0.6) | 71.1% | +4.3 | 1,903 | 14,393 |
| All held back for resistance | 71.5% | +4.7 | 1,921 | 13,020 |
| All committed to the opening fight | 70.9% | +4.1 | 1,892 | 15,777 |
| Against full US mobilization (today's reserves 68.2%) | 72.8% | +4.5 over its own baseline | 2,431 | 16,842 |
| No NATO or allied air (today's reserves 60.5%) | 65.9% | +5.4 over its own baseline | 1,628 | 13,121 |
| Every other module off (today's reserves 56.2%) | 62.7% | +6.4 over its own baseline | 2,175 | 15,782 |
Paired outcomes, today against full (3,000 wars)
- US withdraws either way: 2,003. US wins either way: 847. Unresolved either way: 14.
- Flipped to US withdrawal by the plan: 130 (119 from Canadian capitulation, 11 from consolidated annexation). Flipped the other way: 1.
- The 119 wars rescued from capitulation run longer and cost more: median end month 10 → 26, median Canadian deaths 7,300 → 15,300.
Results: Alberta detachment
US withdrawal with today's reserves is 54.3%.
| Variant | US withdraws | Change |
|---|---|---|
| Full plan | 63.3% | +9.0 (+8.0 to +10.1) |
| All the fighting, no will effect | 57.4% | +3.1 (+2.2 to +4.0) |
| Will effect, no cadres | 59.1% | +4.8 (+4.0 to +5.6) |
| Full plan, linear will effect | 69.4% | +15.1 (+13.9 to +16.4) |
| Best case | 72.3% | +18.0 (+16.7 to +19.4) |
| No NATO or allied air (today's reserves 45.4%) | 55.0% | +9.6 over its own baseline |
Here the fighting helps. The US holds over 90% of the province, so added resistance is felt, and the national pool concentrates on one province.
Results: economic coercion
Coercion succeeds 16.7% of the time with today's reserves and 13.0% with the full plan. With the will effect off it is 16.7%: the whole change is the will effect.
Why the fighting backfires in a full annexation
- The US is already short of troops: it needs 524,000 and can field 372,000. Against the full plan it needs 709,000. Control falls from 57% to 43%, but the occupation was already failing in most runs.
- More fighting kills more on both sides (US deaths +42%, Canadian +39%). In the model Canadian deaths raise the capitulation hazard, and that outweighs the extra pressure on US public support.
Limits and what to fix
- Will effect: a judgement with no data behind it. It decides the size of the answer (4 to 12 points).
- Training: used only in the opening fight. Cadres' effect on the insurgency does not depend on how well they are trained. Next to fix.
- Casualty tolerance: the capitulation hazard does not depend on whether Canada has mobilized. Next to fix.
- Cost and time: mobilization is free and instantaneous.
- Full US mobilization raises US withdrawal slightly (66.8% → 68.2%) through its cost in public support. The harness direction check for this passes on US wins; worth a second look.
Video
video/400k_script.txt is the narration script; video/build_deck.py builds 104 chart frames from these tables; video/align.py and video/assemble.py cut them to a recorded read.